Brands investing heavily in creator partnerships are being urged to rethink how they measure success after new research from Kantar revealed that strong audience engagement rarely translates into meaningful brand impact.

The findings, published in Kantar’s latest Creator Game Plan report, indicate that only six per cent of branded creator content successfully combines high platform engagement with measurable brand building performance.

Consequently, the study challenges one of the creator economy’s most common assumptions that likes, views and shares automatically signal marketing effectiveness.

Drawing insights from more than 15,000 branded creator assets across TikTok, YouTube Shorts and Instagram, the research found that while many campaigns generate impressive social interaction, only a small proportion succeed in strengthening brand perception or driving long term commercial value.

ALSO WATCH:MARKETING EDGE ONTV HOSTS AYODEJI ONABAJO

As a result, marketers are being encouraged to move beyond surface level engagement metrics and adopt more comprehensive methods of evaluating campaign performance.

According to Irene Joshy, Head of Creative at Kantar for Australia and Asia Pacific, the rapidly expanding creator economy continues to reshape marketing across the region.

However, she noted that many campaigns still struggle to maintain a meaningful connection between creators and the brands they represent.

She explained that although approximately one quarter of creator campaigns demonstrate overall effectiveness, the brand itself frequently fails to remain memorable within the content.

ALSO WATCH: CWAY’ S CHILDREN’S DAY SUPERKID CELEBRATION

Therefore, she stressed that cultural relevance has become an increasingly important element of Kantar’s Creator Effectiveness Framework because it enables marketers to preserve creator authenticity while ensuring the brand remains central to the audience experience.

Furthermore, Joshy noted that content performs more effectively when it naturally reflects the communities and conversations that audiences already engage with rather than appearing overly commercial or disconnected from cultural trends.

Echoing that position, Vera Sidlova, Global Creative Director at Kantar, described the findings as an important reminder that popularity on social platforms should not be mistaken for marketing success.

She observed that chief marketing officers are facing increasing pressure to demonstrate measurable returns on creator investments.

Consequently, organisations require stronger performance indicators and more sophisticated testing frameworks to determine whether creator partnerships genuinely contribute to business objectives rather than simply generating online attention.

Sidlova further argued that creative freedom should be viewed as a strategic advantage rather than an optional consideration.

She added that marketers continue to increase investment in creator content because audiences value originality, personality and authenticity.

WATCH ALSO:MARKETING EDGE ONTV HOST DEMILADE

Nevertheless, she maintained that these qualities alone cannot compensate for campaigns that lack clear strategic direction, audience understanding or long term brand relevance.

In response to these industry challenges, Kantar has expanded its LINK AI solution to include dedicated creator content evaluation.

Unlike conventional digital advertising assessments, the enhanced framework measures creator campaigns against benchmarks specifically designed for influencer marketing.

The model evaluates brand building capability, short term sales potential and audience engagement simultaneously, giving marketers a broader understanding of campaign effectiveness.

Meanwhile, Ligia Patrocinio, Global Head of Desperados at Heineken, emphasised that successful creator partnerships demand a fundamentally different mindset from traditional advertising.

She explained that brands diminish the value of creator collaborations whenever they treat creators merely as another advertising placement.

Instead, she argued that the strongest results emerge when creators retain their distinctive voice while operating within clearly defined brand values and audience expectations.

According to Patrocinio, authentic storytelling, cultural relevance and individual personality remain the defining ingredients of successful creator campaigns.

Therefore, brands that encourage creative independence while maintaining strategic alignment are far more likely to build stronger audience relationships and achieve sustainable marketing outcomes.

Overall, the report suggests that the future of creator marketing will depend less on viral engagement and more on the ability to balance authentic storytelling with measurable brand performance.

As competition for consumer attention intensifies, marketers who combine data driven evaluation with culturally relevant creative partnerships are expected to gain a stronger competitive advantage and generate greater long term returns from influencer marketing investments.

WATCH ALSO:MARKETING EDGE ONTV HOSTS YBO