As the public battle between global advertising giants Publicis Groupe and WPP over agency appointments without formal pitches continues to generate debate across the global marketing communications industry, MARKETING EDGE has sought the perspectives of Nigerian professionals on what the controversy means for local agencies, advertisers and the processes guiding client-agency relationships.
Among those who shared their views is Angela Ukara-Makinwa, FNIMN, FRPA, Director, Client Engagement, Strategy & Creative at EXP Marketing Nigeria and Vice President of the Experiential Marketers Association of Nigeria (EXMAN), who believes that while professional relationships can influence agency selection, appointments must be supported by demonstrable capability, proven performance and commercially acceptable terms.
She also called for greater fairness and transparency in competitive pitches, clearer standards for direct appointments and stronger industry intervention to protect agencies from processes that place disproportionate demands on them without adequate compensation.
The debate that prompted the industry-wide conversations centres on whether clients can appoint agencies without conducting formal competitive pitches and still maintain credible due diligence. It became particularly public following comments by Cindy Rose, Chief Executive Officer of WPP, during the company’s third-quarter earnings call on October 29, 2026. Her remarks questioned the growing practice of pitchless appointments and raised concerns about the processes behind such decisions.
ALSO WATCH:MARKETING EDGE ONTV HOSTS IFEANYI UGOARU
Publicis responded on November 5 through an open letter shared on its official Instagram account, rejecting the suggestion that its major account wins were secured through relationships between chief executives. The group argued that the absence of a formal pitch does not mean the absence of due diligence, explaining that client evaluations can take months and involve marketing, technology, data and procurement teams.
Against this backdrop, Ukara-Makinwa said relationships matter in Nigeria, as they do in other markets, particularly when an agency has previously demonstrated its ability to deliver under pressure. However, she maintained that familiarity with a client should not replace a proper assessment of an agency’s competence.
“Relationships matter in Nigeria, as they do in other markets. If a client has seen an agency deliver under pressure, that experience gives the client a reason to consider the agency again. However, the appointment must still be justifiable based on performance, capability and commercial terms.”
She explained that a client could legitimately appoint an agency without conducting a formal pitch where previous performance and a structured assessment provide sufficient evidence of its suitability. Using a national activation as an example, she said a client could examine an agency’s previous results, verify its ability to deploy teams across several states, agree on sales targets and conduct a paid pilot before approving a wider rollout. Such a process, in her view, provides a credible basis for an appointment without requiring agencies to participate in a full competitive pitch.
However, she cautioned against situations in which personal connections become the overriding consideration or agencies are invited to pitch when the client has effectively made its decision. In such circumstances, the process does not provide a meaningful assessment of competing capabilities.
ALSO WATCH:MARKETING EDGE ONTV
Beyond the appointment process, the controversy also raises questions about whether Nigerian agencies can meet the technology, data and operational requirements increasingly associated with major accounts. Ukara-Makinwa believes they can, although she acknowledged that capabilities vary across agencies and that the demands of some international accounts can be substantial.
She identified local consumer knowledge, cultural understanding and familiarity with trade channels as advantages Nigerian agencies can bring to client relationships. The opportunity, she explained, lies in combining those strengths with data and technology to improve campaign delivery and demonstrate commercial results.
For experiential marketing agencies, she noted that technology can help track the journey from product trial to purchase, identify where consumers drop off and allow teams to adjust activation activities while campaigns are still running.
Artificial intelligence can also support faster analysis of field reports, but she maintained that adopting the technology is not, on its own, proof of an agency’s capability. Clients, she said, would still want to know whether the data is reliable, how the agency handles it and what decisions it makes from the information gathered. Those are important considerations in assessing the value an agency brings to a client’s business.
On the fairness of competitive pitches, the EXP Marketing executive said the process can provide a credible basis for selecting agencies, but its design determines which firms can realistically participate. She explained that when advertisers require several agencies to develop complete strategies, creative concepts, production plans and cost estimates at their own expense, firms with greater financial resources have an advantage because they can absorb the cost of unpaid work more easily.
Although international affiliations may provide access to specialist teams, technology and other resources, she said the immediate advantage in such situations could simply be the financial capacity to undertake extensive pitch assignments without guaranteed compensation.
ALSO WATCH:MARKETING EDGE ONTV HOST LYNDA AGUOCHA
To make the process fairer, she advised clients to shortlist agencies based on relevant experience and the strength of the teams that would handle their accounts, rather than requiring every invited agency to undertake extensive work before its suitability has been established. She also called for greater clarity around the expectations placed on agencies during pitches, including the scope of work required and the resources participants are expected to commit.
Turning to the role of industry regulation, Ukara-Makinwa urged the Advertising Regulatory Council of Nigeria (ARCON) to bring advertisers, procurement professionals and agency associations together to develop standards covering both competitive pitches and direct appointments.
For competitive pitches, she said the standards should establish clear requirements, evaluation criteria, scoring systems, decision timelines, pitch-fee arrangements and rules governing the ownership and use of ideas submitted by participating agencies.
For direct appointments, she recommended that clients document the reasons for selecting an agency, how its capabilities and fees were assessed, and whether any conflicts of interest existed. She also placed responsibility on agencies to demonstrate their suitability through credible case studies, clearly identify the teams that would deliver the work and agree with clients on how performance would be measured.
Her position on pitch fees was particularly emphatic, reflecting a concern about the cost agencies incur when participating in competitive selection processes without payment. “Retain Pitch fees, uphold it at all times and pay as long as an agency has participated in the pitch process.”
Her recommendations place pitch compensation, transparency, accountability and clearly documented selection criteria among the issues requiring attention in the relationship between advertisers and agencies. For Ukara-Makinwa, whether a client chooses an agency through a competitive pitch or a direct appointment, the decision should be supported by evidence of capability, a clear assessment process and agreed commercial terms.



Comment
No comments found.