Consumers no longer choose brands in numerous categories. Instead, they are simply reverting to them. From toothpaste to telecommunications, the decision-making process has been reduced to habit. Packaging appears identical and claims sound familiar. Consequently, what remains is automatic behavior. People buy without thinking and switch without emotion.

This is the silent threat of commodification. The problem is not that brands compete too tightly. Rather, it is that they fall into a habit. When consumers are on autopilot, marketing does not persuade. Instead, it interrupts briefly before being dismissed again. This is why many firms spend money on media but struggle to expand. They are apparent but not memorable.

The Trap of Incremental Distinction

Many businesses make the mistake of expecting that louder messages will solve the problem. They try a new color or a slightly improved deal. However, in commodified categories, familiarity is not confidence. In fact, it is obscurity. To stand out, brands must go above and beyond perception by disrupting behavior.

Brands that succeed in crowded categories recognize that capturing attention is the first battle. Before consumers can care, they must be aware. Indeed, noticing is rarely achieved by compliance. It occurs when something feels surprising enough to disrupt habit without appearing alien. This does not necessitate shock techniques. Instead, it demands intent.

Disrupting the Moment of Decision

Some firms defy autopilot by redefining the category itself. They change the question people are accustomed to answering. Others create rituals to make interaction more intentional and deliberate. The goal remains the same: to slow the moment of decision. This allows the brand to re-enter the consumer’s consciousness.

This is where most differentiation attempts fail. They are more concerned with what the brand wants to communicate than with changing behavior. Ultimately, no amount of messaging will change a preference if habits stay unchanged. Growth in these categories is primarily behavioral rather than attitudinal.

The Leadership Challenge

There is also a leadership challenge here. Commoditized markets frequently reward short-term efficiency. As a result, this pushes brands toward homogeneity. Category norms become safety nets, and breaking them seems perilous. However, playing within the rules of a commodified category almost always results in average outcomes.

Brands that avoid this pitfall are rarely the highest spenders. Instead, they are the most deliberate. They select a few different signals and repeat them incessantly. This repetition eventually turns automatic choice into preference.

Experience Over Communication

Importantly, distinction in these sectors must be experienced, not just communicated. If the experience fails at the shelf or during delivery, autopilot returns. Therefore, brand, experience, and operations must be consistent. Distinctiveness cannot exist in isolation.

The true potential in commodified categories is not to outperform competitors. Rather, it is to outlive them. The goal is to create memorable cues and replace habit with attachment. Because when consumers stop thinking, brands disappear. The winning companies are those that offer people a reason to pause.

ALSO WATCH MARKETING EDGE ONTV